In an Elixir Phoenix application that uses LiveView and follows the Umbrella Project structure, you often have two separate apps:

  1. lib/betting_system/ (Core Logic - Contexts)
  2. lib/betting_system_web/ (Web Interface - Web Layer)

🔍 lib/betting_system/ (Core Logic)

This directory is where you define your domain logic and business rules. It typically contains:

  • Contexts: Modules that interact with your database and handle business operations.
  • Schemas: Database schemas that define your data structure (like Ecto.Schema modules).
  • Services: Any core services not related to web delivery.
  • Business Logic: Everything not tied to the web layer directly.

Example structure:

lib/betting_system/
├── betting_system.ex      # Entry point defining your application supervision tree
├── accounts               # Example context (User management, authentication, etc.)
│   ├── accounts.ex
│   └── user.ex
├── betting                # Another context (Managing bets, games, etc.)
│   ├── betting.ex
│   └── game.ex
└── repo.ex                # Ecto Repo definition for database interactions

🔍 lib/betting_system_web/ (Web Interface)

This directory is where your web-related code lives. It handles HTTP requests, LiveView rendering, controllers, views, and templates. It includes:

  • LiveView Modules: Components that handle live, real-time user interfaces.
  • Controllers: Handle incoming requests and map them to the appropriate contexts.
  • Views & Templates: Render HTML pages.
  • Routing: Defines how requests are mapped to controllers or LiveView modules.

Example structure:

lib/betting_system_web/
├── betting_system_web.ex       # Web interface entry point
├── controllers                 # Standard Phoenix controllers
│   ├── page_controller.ex
│   └── user_controller.ex
├── live                        # LiveView modules
│   ├── user_live.ex
│   └── betting_live.ex
├── templates                   # HTML templates
│   ├── layout.html.heex
│   └── user
├── router.ex                   # Routes for HTTP and LiveView requests
└── endpoint.ex                 # Configures and starts the web interface

Key Differences

Aspect lib/betting_system/ lib/betting_system_web/
Purpose Business Logic (Core) User Interface (Web Layer)
Contains Contexts, Schemas, Services Controllers, LiveViews, Templates
Data Handling Defines schemas, interacts with DB Displays data to users (HTML, LiveView)
Dependencies Pure Elixir (No Phoenix dependency) Phoenix (Controllers, LiveView)
Reusability Can be reused without Phoenix Tied to Phoenix Framework

📌 Why This Separation?

  • Separation of Concerns: Keeps business logic separate from presentation logic.
  • Testability: Easier to test core logic without involving web interface.
  • Reusability: The core logic (lib/betting_system/) can be used independently of the web interface.